How are reviews garnered and how do you determine a score when a critic does not use a 5-star rating system?



Reviews are compiled from an approved set of critics by inserting their respective ratings into a formula that calculates the TQ Score. The formula is quite simply the “# of critics who gave the album 3 stars or better” divided by the “# of critics who’s reviews were compiled for that album”.

Most critics will provide readers with a score, whether that be a based on a 5-star system, out of 10 points, or even a letter grade. These scores are then proportionally converted into a 5-star system. For reviewers who do not using a scoring system the score applied is up to the editorial staff to determine based upon the general impression of the review. Critics who seem indecisive or who are “riding the fence” on a review are usually given a rating of 2.5 stars or less because if the critic doesn’t have enough confidence in the album to recommend it then Throwing Quarters doesn’t either.